So, Liz and I have been examining the pro's and con's to medi-share the "Christian Care Medical Sharing" program. We've found some things that concern us, some things that make me excited, and some things that I'm not so sure about.
First, the Pro's;
1. This is a fairly biblical model for Christ's people to share the costs of each other's bills and burdens. If this were able to catch on to every true Christian, this would be a massive testimony to the world.
2. The monthly payments, (contribution to other people's bills) are fairly close to what you would normally pay for regular insurance if not a little less.
3. The program seems to be concerned just as much about the lifestyle/prayer life of the members as much as it is the physical well-being of the people involved.
The Con's
1. The care of people is limited to believers, (understandably necessary considering the fact that believers live such a radically different life-style which is often healthier than that of non-believers).
2. Repeated disclaimers make it clear that this is NOT insurance and that there is NO guarantee that the bills you incur will be paid. Should the company cease to function or if no volunteers decide to pay your bills, you're still responsible for paying your bills. There is no guarantee that you will have your bills taken care of.
3. Each hospital visit and bill will be examined and scrutinized to ensure that there are no signs of "misbehavior" according to the rules. Should you sin, you're subject to lose all availability for "sharing", meaning that they can just instantly choose not to pay your bills should they not like the "sin" you're in, leaving little room for God's grace in all of this.
4. With the costs being pretty much the same as other health insurance companies, there is less security in making sure things are taken care of bill-wise.
5. Rates can increase without notice should the income be less than the outgoing costs of bills. Meaning if everyone starts to get sick at once, the cost of your "medi-share" can go up, (though in 16 years they say this has never happened.)
6. If the world suffered a traumatic event such as the plague or some major bird-flu pandemic, it is likely medical costs would sky-rocket, causing this to cost a whole-lot more where as with insurance your premium always stays the same.
The Uncertainties:
1. According to the brochure, the company has been in business for 16 years and has paid 500 million in bills. This does not seem like a large amount, especially with the sky-rocketing rate of hospital bills these days. Doing the math, there are 12 months in a year, at 16 years, which comes to 192 months of activity. Which equals a little more than 2.6 million a month in hospital bills paid. Certainly seems like a large number!
During that time if there are only 1,000 members who have medical bills, (my assumption is generous if they have any more than 5,000 members), that means they are only paying about 2,604 in hospital bills every month for those who are going to the doctors office/hopsital.
This to me leaves me uncertain. I have a friend who says that even after insurance he is paying 5,500 for some ear surgery he has to have. This is one of many hospital bills he has had. Another friend of mine has been having a lot of diagnostic tests done and he is dealing with hospital bills that are 5,000-7,000. 2,604 a month doesn't seem like a whole lot in light of that, but it could just be that everyone who is a part of this is chronically healthy.
So what do you think?
No comments:
Post a Comment